I'm guessing it's the MALE GAZE (although even then, I don't understand how you could defend him).

 

To be honest - I actually feel sorry for Frankie. He's been set up something mercilessly and been led to believe that he's something he's not. People have accused Louis of being cruel with his criticism last night - I think Barlow has been far more cruel.

 

In Frankie's defence - I'd rather have had him last night than Janet (of whom I was sure Louis was going to say 'Why you're like a little Sonja!')

 

Kath

Edited November 6, 201113 yr by Kath

On what planet does Frankie have a 'voice' to like?

 

 

Janet was abysmal last night. She started off rather good, then after she forgot the words she descended into a squealing banshee.

 

Johnny was utterly dire at Hung Up (The song itself remains terminally shit) but You Spin Me Round was completely magnificent.

 

Misha, Marcus and Kitty remained outstanding. Craig was also very good and I adore that song.

 

I hope BixMix stay as they continued their promising momentum from last week and I'm slowly getting on board with them. The Risk however, I don't think are as good as they were pre-line up change.

And with the greatest respect to you, I don't see what relevance that has? I didn't say everyone else's perspective is skewed, I said I'm miffed at Marcus' popularity. I admit that's because my perspective is 'skewed' (at least in comparison to everyone else's) but that's still my perspective and I'm going to post it if that's what I think. I think Marcus is okay but in no way the best person in the competition like everyone else says.

 

I bring up your applauding of Janet, because it was a useful example of how STRANGE your opinions on the X Factor have been this week. It's as if you've taken on Jark's mantra of being CONTRARY to EVERYTHING. Implying that Marcus is overrated is essentially the same as saying everybody's perspective on him is skewed, hence my comment.

Your opinion is of course your own, but I did not at any point say you SHOULDN'T post it. But you should be prepared to justify it. I was merely trying to question on what possible planet Janet, who forgot her words, could be a 9/10, whilst Marcus who was in all objectivity, note-perfect, is "overrated"?

So! I predict the best ones to go and Frankie to suffer another week of knowing he shouldn't really be there.

 

I wonder how many youtube hits JLS and FloMac have had?

REf***INGCAP TIME!

I love how Gary tries to belittle Louis and ends up looking more foolish.

They really are awful at miming

Even in recap, Janet's dancing was pretty bad.

 

And LOLZ at Gary's message to The Risk; what BETTER way to DESTROY a band than to start telling them who the lead singer should be? You'd think Gary of ALL people should know where that road leads...

The reason Gary wouldn't say anything like that to one of Louis's acts is that his acts can sing. The fact that Frankie is still here over Sami is astounding.

This JLS single really is INCREDIBLY DULL isn't it? Number One with a bullet undoubtedly though.

The reason Gary wouldn't say anything like that to one of Louis's acts is that his acts can sing. The fact that Frankie is still here over Sami is astounding.

 

He says it to Johnny all the time though!

Dear God, That was DULLER than dishwater, Florence to upstage them please

X Factor Finalists Charity single in adverts! :o

Eurgh at this new advert. Why let Frankie on it? Although I do wish Misha would sing like that more often.

Am I REALLY seeing a Bruce Forsyth album being advertised called "These Are My Favourites"? I am LOST FOR WORDS.

Misha sounded great on the advert :wub:

On what planet does Frankie have a 'voice' to like?

 

I felt that during the auditions and bootcamp Frankie had a likeable enough voice. It was only in the live shows I started greatly disliking him.

 

Now he just has this I couldn't give a damn feeling about his voice.

Florence sounds GREAT. I thought this could have been disastrous but it's pretty great so far...

Oh good god. I really hate this thing.

 

 

In comparison I positively LOVED JLS' dull Dildo impression.

Thought we were getting the massively superior 'No Light, No Light' :(! At least this could become a good sized hit though now, after underperforming massively.