Jump to content

Featured Replies

Posted

AF Idol Spin-Off: Round 2 Reflection

Theme: Album Closers

 

Thank you to the 32 voters who took part in this round! Jonjo and I have counted and verified the results. The results:

 

Pos / Points / Song (ties unbroken)

01 28 Mariah Carey - Prisoner

02 27 Tove Lo - hey you got drugs?

03 22 Carly Rae Jepsen - When I Needed You

03 22 Tinashe - Wildfire

05 21 Janet Jackson - Better Days

06 18 Rachel Stevens - Dumb Dumb

07 17 Röyksopp feat. Jamie Irrepressible - Something In My Heart

08 15 Gorillaz - Demon Days

08 15 Kelly Clarkson - Beautiful Disaster (Live)

10 13 Kim Petras - Everybody Dies

11 12 Greyson Chance - More Than Me

11 12 Maren Morris - Company You Keep

13 11 The Weeknd - Die for You

14 10 Hailee Steinfeld - Hell Nos and Headphones

15 09 Coldplay - Up With the Birds

16 04 Pixie Lott - Use Somebody

 

Round 3: COLLABORATIONS / REMIXES

 

Please confirm your song entries by 6pm on 24th July 2020. Round 3 will be going live for voting afterwards! Get discussing potential songs in the AF Hub threads and pre-order Folklore! https://store.taylorswift.com/

  • Replies 17
  • Views 507
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Yassssss the folklore promotion :cheeseblock: we love to see it! <3 (come post in the Tay forum and vote in the many new polls today too! x)

the way I was gonna edit in folklore promotion into this post and you already did it for me Jay *.* <3

 

Maren coming joint 11th is fab to see, glad she's not struggling too much on the whole <3 also yay for Hailee coming 14th, in hindsight maybe I should've gone with flashlight but I was expecting it to be 15th here ahaha :lol:

OMG. Tinashe :cheeseblock: A podium finish! :wub:

 

Glad to see Kelly managed to get top half... just/in a tie! Now can y'all stop paying her dust!!!

 

---

 

Tove with ANOTHER 2nd place finish. THE UNDERDOG *.* What a fantastic top 2 though. Both discoveries and two of my absolute fave discoveries across all the AF Idol's I think!

Honestly over the moon with Röyksopp finishing 7th as this was the round I was dreading the most, or at least the round where I knew I wouldn't be able to send a particular favourite of mine.

 

Great result for Mariah, smashed it! :o

The disrespect to Coldplay has begun :frankie: well at least they beat Pixie xx

 

All of my other votes are in the top 8 though and the remainder of the results pretty closely tracks my ranking of the songs I didn't vote for so that particular lack of taste aside I can't complain too much, even the Mariah song was good :magic: Pleasantly surprised that Röyksopp managed to do so well again without the aid of Robyn this time!

 

Greyson not coming last :clap: (this song wasn't as good as the one in round 1 though xx but I guess he'll tend to do better in rounds where he isn't competing against mostly songs that everyone already knows)

  • Author

:o :heart: I am so pleasantly surprised that Mariah won this round! Prisoner was something of a discovery for me too, given I'd barely heard it before preparing for this contest - glad that many of you like it too! :wub:

 

rs_500x281-161128142132-MARIAHS-WORLD-MARIAH-CAREY-10.gif

 

Also great to see Carly within the Top 3 (my forthcoming comment may seem daft considering that great placement, but I was a little surprised that a few people seemed rather indifferent to it, but I will attempt to not go fully Carly Loon on y'all x #downloadandstreamEMOTION)

 

Lots of great songs from this round, many I hadn't heard before and I will happily revisit again, including Tove Lo, Tinashe and Janet. I'm particularly happy that Greyson did better in this round than last time! Also great to see Rachel Stevens that high up the results #downloadandstreamComeandGetIt

Pretty much all the best tracks fared well in this, hooray! the Mariah/Tove/Janet songs sounded really good on the listenthru, another great result for Royksopp as well

 

Oops at Pixie!

 

Happy for Greyson though :wub: :clap: Hopefully he can creep up more as the rounds go on too!

Oh hey I didn't expect the results would match my rank so closely (apart from Carly). I'm surprised Pixie didn't benefit a little from being a cover of a well-known song.
Oh hey I didn't expect the results would match my rank so closely (apart from Carly). I'm surprised Pixie didn't benefit a little from being a cover of a well-known song.

I think it actually hindered her! The original is an incredible and hugely popular song, her cover sucked out all life from this so it actually sounded blasphemous and even worse knowing the original.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.