Posted May 18, 20214 yr Rank all the Sugababes members and feel free to explain your reasons why :) For me 1. Amelle 2. Mutya 3. Keisha 4. Heidi 5. Siobhan 6. Jade Amelle is my favourite, I just love her personality and she has a great voice too. Mutya again, really strong and distinctive voice and had some great solo releases after leaving the band. I feel a bit sour at Siobhan for leaving so early before the band had properly even taken off so I feel like she contributed less to the band than Heidi did. I know she had her reasons for leaving due to her own struggles. Jade never really got her time to shine in the band as we never got the 4.0 album.
May 18, 20214 yr 1. Mutya, Keisha, Siobhan in a tie. 2. Heidi I really just like all of the 1.0 girls these days for various reasons that I can't really pick one. Heidi contributed a lot and made a decent replacement for Siobhan.
May 18, 20214 yr For me, Mutya will always be my absolute number 1 but I do love all of the original trio equally. Mutya Keisha/Siobhan Amelle Heidi I don't count the other one. Recently 1.0 overtook 2.0 as my favourite line up. Been really loving the leaks and listening to them heaps and they've edged ahead of 2.0 now.
May 19, 20214 yr Siobhan Keisha Mutya Heidi Amelle Jade This is my ranking as well. I just adore Siobhan, her solo work has been exceptional :wub: Keisha is definitely my number two and feels, to me, like the key member of the Sugababes. Mutya is close, although I do have to say I went slightly off her last year with all her conspiracy theories.
May 19, 20214 yr Honestly if I had to pick a member that just defined Sugababes it's Mutya - can you honestly be cooler or sexier than her? It doesn't matter what she wears, it doesn't matter what she says she's just Mutya and you will deal with it.
May 19, 20214 yr This is my ranking as well. I just adore Siobhan, her solo work has been exceptional :wub: Keisha is definitely my number two and feels, to me, like the key member of the Sugababes. Mutya is close, although I do have to say I went slightly off her last year with all her conspiracy theories. 100% Siobhan’s solo,output is just phenomenal! I’ve also always loved Keisha’s voice and Mutya whilst she’s got a great voice I can take or leave her.
May 19, 20214 yr Is it a surprise? With 1 album and 1 single additional she has had the same number of releases as Siobhan technically but Jades is on the most hated album and most hated song where the vocals are heavily programmed and autotuned. In comparison, none of Siobhans vocals have ever been near either of those things. Jade never really made a mark. I forget she was even in the band a lot of the time
May 19, 20214 yr 01 Siobhan - although largely for Ghosts :wub: 02 Mutya 03 Keisha 04 Heidi 05 Amelle 06 Jade
May 24, 20214 yr Mutya was my fav growing up but I also had a soft spot for Keisha, so I can't choose between them. never really cared for the others in terms of personality, but for voices/preference I would then say Amelle > Jade > Heidi/Siobhan Edited May 24, 20214 yr by jsweetxe
May 24, 20214 yr Siobhan Keisha Mutya Heidi Amelle I could happily talk about how underrated Siobhan is for hours.
May 24, 20214 yr As a Sugababe: 1. Keisha - It was always Mutya before however I can't deny Keisha's incredible commitment to the band and now all these years later I think it's disgusting how she got kicked out of the band. Sugababes are not Sugababes without Keisha! 2. Mutya - That voice! She has one of the best voices in music ever for me such a unique husky tone it's stunning. She also gave the girls a bit of grit back in the day that they didn't have after she left. 3. Heidi - Rounding off the sacred three (for me). Heidi's addition to the group is part of what really made them take off as she brought a bit of a softer tone to the group. Mutya, Keisha and Siobhan were a bit too moody and they needed Heidi to be a bit more commercial - and it really took off for them! 4. Amelle - She fitted into Mutya's role quite nicely and made the group a bit more glamourous. She definitely played her role in the group and having About you now as part of her time gives her major props - the most played song on radio of the 00's decade supposedly. 5. Siobhan - I feel like Siobhan gets a bit too much credit from the fan base. Her role as a Sugababe has left a lot to be desired for me. She barely lasted 5 minutes before she legged it and then she blamed Keisha for being a bully (this is where it all started) something which she has never commented on since (as far as I am aware) which always leaves a bit of a sour taste in my mouth regarding her. Don't get me wrong Amelle said the same but at least she has never gone back to a group with her in it. If we were talking about them as solo artists however Siobhan would be #1 as Ghost is a fantastic album! 6. Jade - I don't even view her as a Sugababe.
