Jump to content

Featured Replies

Posted

O8WdrnZ.jpg

 

Thank you to everyone who posted their rates, now time for the results! B-)

  • Replies 123
  • Views 8.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Author

 

13. Shanti / Ashtangi // 6.75 average

Highest: one 9 // Lowest: three 5s

  • Author
This is last place for me on the album but still a solid 7/10. There's actually quite a few hooks here, despite not recognising what is being said, and I really like heavy, hypnotic production.
I thought that one was decent enough, gave it an 8, wasn't my least fave though and I like the music style of it too.

Not sure how i know the words to Shanti lol, was always going to come last.

 

I have a feeling that Mer Girl will be next but i hope it isnt

Fully expected this track to be out first.

 

It's actually not that bad a track and could probably be rating as good - but up against the other tracks here it was always going to fall.

 

Agree! A great track but going off the strength of the album, it was always going to falter. I love the experimentation of it from such a huge pop star.
I guess that was always the obvious last place... albeit I really enjoy it these days and a couple of others have slipped behind it now. The production feels really appropriate for the subject matter - although I accept that's a UK view... apparently Madge doesn't actually do a good job with the language according to those who speak it.
Ahhh I didn’t vote in this but Mer Girl would have been high up for me!
I didn’t take part as I barely know the album and one listen through wouldn’t be fair but Frozen is my all time favourite Madonna song. So I’m here for that winning.
^ its time you gave the album a listen, you wont regret it
Definitely not the worst (least good) song on the album, but I can see why it has come last due to not being in English.
The standard was so high that my lowest score was a 7 and ’Shanti / Ashtangi’ received one of the four I dished out, so not too fussed about it exiting first
  • Author

 

12. Mer Girl // 6.975 average

Highest: one 9.5 // Lowest: two 5s

^ shame , was hoping this would beat CPG

 

this track is just spine tingling

'Mer Girl' is haunting. A stunning end to the album but it isn't one that I can return to outside the context of the album so I am not fussed that it has fared lower here.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.