Jump to content

Featured Replies

12 hours ago, GreyAsh said:

I think everything I was going to say has been covered! I don’t feel there is anything in recent chart history, that would allow CMAT to be credited - and inherit a chart hit that old and that big. It goes against their rules - and if that rule can be broken, I’m sure it could also be granted a reset.

Part of me thinks that would never happen, and the other part of me feels that it was a negotiation that Amazon would have had with the OCC.

But Faouzia’s Chart Update position 😍 - quite a shock for it to be that high. I can’t actually see why it is so high, unless it is growing on another platform. But either way, it is highly likely to be in the top 40.

I would say Elton and Robyn will be out and Faouzia and Ariana will be in.

I was surprised that Wham! didn’t climb into the top 10! But I think they will overtake Sienna Spiro and maybe Olivia Dean by the end of the week.

What happened with Lana Del Rey - Summertime Sadness? Did they remove Cedric Gervais from being credited when it re-entered 10 years later? I might be mis-remembering, but I vaguely remember that happening and being quite surprised as I assumed he'd be credited forever as it was the "single version" of the song. But if that did happen then that means a song's credits can change after a long time.

  • Replies 322
  • Views 18.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

Posted Images

5 minutes ago, Eric_Blob said:

What happened with Lana Del Rey - Summertime Sadness?

Good spot! I don’t know the story here - so I can’t remember whether Cedric Gervais was credited initially. I have a feeling he was credited as the lead artist, though, wasn’t he, not Lana initially? If that’s the case, it’s even more bizarre.

Edit: looking back through the reviews here, according to @Bror

‘Lana Del Rey vs. Cedric Gervais Summertime Sadness’

It makes more sense to remove an artist now that we are firmly in the streaming era, because multiple versions of the same songs would contribute, and this was just a remix. But adding an artist to a record that has already been so successful, just seems nonsense.

Globally the original version of ‘Summertime Sadness’ has received more streams. 2.5 billion compared with 0.89 billion.

Edited by GreyAsh

this is probably a testament to us lightly underestimating Becky. She's def staying top 10 by friday!

I'm really impressed with how well Becky Hill is charting considering the album feels like it has no hype. Coupled with no hits and her appearing to be the sort of act who would appeal to the GP and not have a solid fanbase, that's a great result.

15 hours ago, Bror said:

I see 'Starburster' is back in the chart replacing 'Marianne' - although it's ahead of 'Mimesis' too so might have been back this week regardless. Has it been reset? (Presumably a few weeks ago if so).

2 versions of 'Fairytale Of New York' charting *.

I hated TASPOM oop x (but the other singles from the album were good to great, she deserves better than for that to be her chart peak)

‘I Don’t Really Care For You’ deserve all the success her current stuff gets, by far her best song (and 6 weeks at no1 on my chart)!

Interested to see what Team Becky do to try and maintain a high position - she already added multiple extra album launch shows last week to generate some additional sales, she’s done the standard Banquet signed which probably haven’t been added yet but aside from price reductions there’s probably not much left for them to do.

For those hoping to see ‘UNETHICAL’ making the top 40 this week - it is now charting in USA and climbing the global chart.

It is also in the Amazon and Apple Pop Charts - so is roughly 110 and 220 on those platforms (behind loads of songs on ACR).

IMG_1077.jpeg

IMG_1079.jpeg

12 hours ago, GreyAsh said:

Good spot! I don’t know the story here - so I can’t remember whether Cedric Gervais was credited initially. I have a feeling he was credited as the lead artist, though, wasn’t he, not Lana initially? If that’s the case, it’s even more bizarre.

Edit: looking back through the reviews here, according to @Bror

‘Lana Del Rey vs. Cedric Gervais Summertime Sadness’

It makes more sense to remove an artist now that we are firmly in the streaming era, because multiple versions of the same songs would contribute, and this was just a remix. But adding an artist to a record that has already been so successful, just seems nonsense.

Globally the original version of ‘Summertime Sadness’ has received more streams. 2.5 billion compared with 0.89 billion.

Well, I'm not really that bothered by it, but removing Cedric Gervais from being credited seemed to go against the OCC's usual rules, which is why I was so surprised. Before it used to be the case that the label would specify which is the single version (i.e. the main version), and that version would be what's credited, forever, no matter which version of the song is selling or streaming the most.

So Summertime Sadness should always be credited to Cedric Gervais, even if it's the original or one of the other remixes getting the most streams.

So what I think happened is the label treated it's resurgence like a re-release and said now the original is the single version.

Either that or the OCC have changed how they do things now.

I don't think it could've possibly been a mistake because it would've automatically come up on their database as credited to Cedric Gervais, so they'd have had to intentionally and manually change it.

So I have no clue what happened there honestly. I think, if the rules are like before, if Elton John's label treat this as a re-release with the CMAT version as the single version he can be credited (and would be indefinitely from now on). If the OCC have changed how it's done then I have absolutely no idea lol

58 minutes ago, Eric_Blob said:

Well, I'm not really that bothered by it, but removing Cedric Gervais from being credited seemed to go against the OCC's usual rules, which is why I was so surprised. Before it used to be the case that the label would specify which is the single version (i.e. the main version), and that version would be what's credited, forever, no matter which version of the song is selling or streaming the most.

So Summertime Sadness should always be credited to Cedric Gervais, even if it's the original or one of the other remixes getting the most streams.

So what I think happened is the label treated it's resurgence like a re-release and said now the original is the single version.

Either that or the OCC have changed how they do things now.

I don't think it could've possibly been a mistake because it would've automatically come up on their database as credited to Cedric Gervais, so they'd have had to intentionally and manually change it.

So I have no clue what happened there honestly. I think, if the rules are like before, if Elton John's label treat this as a re-release with the CMAT version as the single version he can be credited (and would be indefinitely from now on). If the OCC have changed how it's done then I have absolutely no idea lol

Wasn't it simply a case that I'm 2013 it was just Summertime Sadness (Cedric Gervais Remix) rather than him having an actual artist credit on the billing with her?

24 minutes ago, Jessie Where said:

Wasn't it simply a case that I'm 2013 it was just Summertime Sadness (Cedric Gervais Remix) rather than him having an actual artist credit on the billing with her?

He was part of the OCC credit: "Lana Del Rey vs. Cedric Gervais".

Polyhex have actually given the song separate chart runs: under that name for 2013-14, and just to "Lana Del Rey" in 2022.

Still not sure how they'll credit Elton/CMAT, though I notice on the page for "Elton John", 'Step Into Christmas' now appears as 'Elton John's Christmas EP', though it's still credited just to him. However if you click on its chart run and select any date, it still shows as 'Step Into Christmas' by Elton John.

The idea of CMAT being credited on a song in the chart of 1973, two decades before she was born, is pretty ludicrous. I suppose they could start a new chart run for the song credited to both of them, but it would still feel inauthentic - even this year, the majority of its streams (especially the voluntary ones) will come from the original version.

Faouzia ‘UNETHICAL’ has entered the Apple top 200 at 192. I think this is for the first time.

It it also seems to be somewhere in the top 120 on Amazon.

In both charts it seems to be approximately the 23rd biggest SCR song, and about half of those SCR songs above it are songs that have had a reset, and several of the others are ones that keep escaping ACR.

Could Feist and "My moon my man" get a reset and into the top 40?

7 hours ago, GreyAsh said:

Faouzia ‘UNETHICAL’ has entered the Apple top 200 at 192. I think this is for the first time.

It it also seems to be somewhere in the top 120 on Amazon.

In both charts it seems to be approximately the 23rd biggest SCR song, and about half of those SCR songs above it are songs that have had a reset, and several of the others are ones that keep escaping ACR.

Can I ask why this is rising is it because its viral or just on a playlist?

30 minutes ago, Steve201 said:

Can I ask why this is rising is it because its viral or just on a playlist?

I assume it has just been slowly building. Its ascent has been very slow. In fact it was thought to be on DCL-2, so it’s been a very slow ascent.

FCP Wednesday New Logo.png

Music Week Top 40 Sales Flash

Singles

right 01 Jamie Miller - Babydoll (39,551)

right 02 Ashe - Stop the Wedding! (22,270)

up 03 sombr - My Body Isn't Ready (17,436)

down 04 Tate McRae - Housewife (16,968)

down 05 SIENNA SPIRO - Great Expectation (16,130)

up 07 ADÉLA - Nicole Kidman

up 08 Sam Fender & Olivia Dean - Rein Me In

up 09 Wham! - Last Christmas (9,802)

up 10 Olivia Dean - Man I Need

up 12 P!nk feat. Nate Ruess - Just Give Me a Reason

up 14 Taylor Swift - Patient Zero

up 15 Mariah Carey - All I Want for Christmas Is You (7,931)

up 16 Noah Kahan - Willing and Able

up 17 Justice, Tame Impala, SZA & King Gizzard & the Lizard Wizard - Flower in a Hurricane

up 18 Season 25 - Shotta's.

up 19 Kingfishr - The Sun Will Never Settle

up 22 Alex Warren - Ordinary

up 26 STELLA LEFTY - Boston

re 29 Kelly Clarkson - Underneath the Tree

re 31 Brenda Lee - Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree

re 32 Elton John - Step Into Christmas

re 34 The Pogues feat. Kirsty MacColl - Fairytale of New York

up 36 Grace - Not Over Yet

re 37 Ariana Grande - Santa Tell Me

up 38 HUGEL, Imael Angel & Ultra Naté - Movin' to the Sun

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Albums

ne 01 U2 - Carnaval De Luz (39,515)

up 02 Olivia Rodrigo - you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love (7,604)

ne 03 Jake Bugg - Alamo (5,935)

up 04 Noah Kahan - The Great Divide (5,659)

ne 05 Becky Hill - REBECCA (5,410)

up 06 Michael Jackson - The Essential

up 07 Olivia Dean - The Art of Loving

up 08 Fontaines D.C. - Dopamine Chamber

ne 09 Scarlet Rebels - Flawed by Design

up 15 Noah Kahan - Stick Season

re 22 Aphex Twin - Drukqs

ne 24 Midge Ure - Chapters: The Best Of

re 34 Girls Aloud - Out of Control

ne 39 The Clash - The World According to the Clash

On Monday, Babydoll was 1744 units below Monday last week

Tonight, Babydoll is only 1037 units down on Wednesday last week

Can Babydoll avoid going to 2 weeks of decline on Friday ?

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 1