Come To Mama single-handedly saves this album :wub: I didn't think I'd ever love a Gaga song this much again lol

 

Joanne is beautiful, Diamond Heart might grow on me. I'm only on Hey Girl and the album is better than I was expecting! So much better than Artpop

I absolutely loved this, definitely beat my expectations! Loving all the songs and Come To Mama/A-Yo/Angel Down/John Wayne/Sinner's Prayer are my highlights :wub: (Along with PI and Million Reasons which has hit me!)

 

My only two little complaints is that it feels like some of the songs just end and finish really suddenly and that there is no Gypsy/most of Fame/BTW 11/10 Gaga-moment :(

Ooh. A couple more 'Come To Mama' lovers <3

Has this flopped yet?

John Wayne tho OMG

http://i.imgur.com/VzGNkJe.gif

Initial rate, all the tracks are pretty lovely so no low scores really. Ayo, Diamond Heart and Sinner's Prayer are my top 3 with Perfect Illusion and Million Reasons not too far behind.

 

09.5 Diamond Heart

09.5 A-YO

07.5 Joanne

06.5 John Wayne

07.0 Dancin' In Circles

08.5 Perfect Illusion

08.5 Million Reasons

09.0 Sinner's Prayer

08.0 Come To Mama

07.5 Hey Girl

06.5 Angel Down

07.0 Grigio Girls

06.0 Just Another Day

 

This album is actually really solid, loving CountryGa more than I expected. Diamond Heart needs more love around here...

 

Also, I'm in the yay go Come to Mama side, it is going to sound amazing during the upcoming winter Christmas period.

http://mobile.nytimes.com/2016/10/20/arts/...oanne.html?_r=0

 

The reviews are savage.

10 Diamond Heart (I need this as a single with some killer remixes)

07.5 A-YO

08 Joanne

10 John Wayne (Amazing)

07.0 Dancin' In Circles

11 Perfect Illusion (One of her best singles ever)

10 Million Reasons (Gorgeous and would work as a single)

10 Sinner's Prayer (I like how dark and mellow this is)

08.0 Come To Mama

04 Hey Girl (I hate Florence on this)

07 Angel Down

08 Grigio Girls

05 Just Another Day (A bit "meh, this is a bit meh")

10 Angel Down (Work Tape) (Her voice on this verison works with the lyrics so much better)

 

On the whole, I like this more than everything bar BTW. THe slight country sound to some of the songs is a welcome addition but it's hardly a country

Grigio Girls sounds like something that would have been on the Juno soundtrack. I like it a lot more after watching her perform it last night.

keep putting off listening to this cos i know I'm gonna be disappointed and i don't want to be

 

most people ranking a-yo as their fav when i found it bland af doesn't help either

09 Diamond Heart

08 A-YO

07 Joanne

10 John Wayne

08 Dancin' In Circles

10 Perfect Illusion

06 Million Reasons

08 Sinner's Prayer

06 Come To Mama

08 Hey Girl

09 Angel Down

07 Grigio Girls

07 Just Another Day

08 Angel Down

 

This is way better than I'd expected! John Wayne is definitely the best for me, there's just something about it I love. :wub:

Edited October 21, 20169 yr by Andr00w

08 Diamond Heart

10 A-Yo

07 Joanne

09 John Wayne

11 Dancin' In Circles

10 Perfect Illusion

08 Million Reasons

05 Sinner's Prayer

03 Come To Mama

06 Hey Girl

06 Angel Down

08 Grigio Girls

07 Just Another Day

06 Angel Down (Work Tape)

 

Consider my expectations exceeded at least! A lovely album though her weakest so far. Goes a bit downhill post-Million Reasons, on first listen.

 

Can already feel that 'A-Yo', 'Dancin' In Circles' and 'John Wayne' are going to be addictive :wub:

 

'Angel Down' seems like a possible grower.

Just bought it *.*

On my 2nd listen through now and now I know what to expect, I'm actually really liking the album!

 

08.0 Diamond Heart > I actually think this would make a great single. <

07.0 A-Yo

07.5 Joanne

08.0 John Wayne

09.0 Dancin' In Circles

07.0 Perfect Illusion

10.0 Million Reasons

08.0 Sinner's Prayer

10.0 Come To Mama

05.0 Hey Girl > Would probably be a 7 at least if there was a better guest vocalist than the banshee that is currently featured! :puke: <

07.0 Angel Down

 

Very nice album. Not one that I get the urge to go back to often, but it's a really pleasant listen! :wub: (It's OK. This can be her 'My December'/'Try This' era)

Very nice album. Not one that I get the urge to go back to often, but it's a really pleasant listen! :wub: (It's OK. This can be her 'My December'/'Try This' era)

 

Wasn't she meant to have that with ARTPOP? :lol:

Wasn't she meant to have that with ARTPOP? :lol:

Shush. :kink:

This is an album I don't think I'm gonna go back to, I'm a bit disappointed tbh I just found it really boring :no: It's maybe just not my thing though. I do like John Wayne, Dancin' In Circles, Hey Girl (Gaga and Florence's voices go together surprisingly well :o), Grigio Girls and Diamond Heart but even those aren't at the standard I was expecting :unsure:

 

Perfect Illusion is still the best tho

 

I'M SORRY

 

I'll do a rate since others have, I just realised I listened to the Deluxe on Spotify so will just go with that :kink:

 

08.0 Diamond Heart

07.0 A-Yo

04.0 Joanne

08.0 John Wayne

08.0 Dancin' In Circles

09.0 Perfect Illusion

04.5 Million Reasons

06.0 Sinner's Prayer

07.0 Come To Mama

08.0 Hey Girl

04.0 Angel Down

08.5 Grigio Girls

07.5 Just Another Day

Edited October 21, 20169 yr by LINDSΞY

Awful album. I can't even get through it. Had to stop playing as I used up my 5 spotify skips.

 

02.0 Diamond Heart

10.0 A-Yo

02.0 Joanne

03.0 John Wayne

05.0 Dancin' In Circles

06.0 Perfect Illusion

04. Million Reasons

02.0 Sinner's Prayer

--Come To Mama

03.0 Hey Girl

02.0 Angel Down

1. Grigio Girls

-- Just Another Day

06.0 Diamond Heart

04.0 A-Yo

06.0 Joanne

09.0 John Wayne

07.0 Dancin' In Circles

10.0 Perfect Illusion

06.5 Million Reasons

08.0 Sinner's Prayer

08.5 Come To Mama

10.0 Hey Girl

05.5 Angel Down

07.0 Grigio Girls

07.0 Just Another Day

06.0 Angel Down [Work Tape]

 

Hey Girl, John Wayne, Sinner's Prayer and Come To Mama are all glorious (with Perfect Illusion) :wub:

Edited October 21, 20169 yr by HarryEzra