We haven't had this yet!

 

I've tried to pick S Club & Steps songs that fall into a similar sound/category to compare like for like!

Steps all the way! (except for DSM and NHADCT)

steps for every single one x

S Club 7

5, 6, 7, 8

S Club Party

Reach

Don't Stop Movin

Never Had a Dream Come True

Have You Ever

You

 

Kinda surprised myself there but I prefer most of these S Club songs to the Steps ones, maybe partly due to me listening to S Club more than usual lately! Although I admit I doubt any of them could beat Scared Of The Dark tbh

The songs:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Edited April 12, 20205 yr by fl00zy*

S club all the way. Was nevee a Steps fan

I really like S Club but Steps are my next big band love after Spice Girls and Scissor Sisters so I have to say Steps, adore them!

 

Steps

Bring it all back

Tragedy

Reach

Don’t stop moving

It’s the way you make me feel

One for sorrow

Deeper shade of blue

I went for S Club over Steps - mainly cause some of the Steps hits were covers of songs I already liked!

 

5,6,7,8

Tragedy

Reach

Don't Stop Movin

Never Had A Dream Come True

Have You Ever

Deeper Shade of Blue

S Club 7 vs Steps

 

Bring it All Back vs 5, 6, 7, 8

S Club Party vs Tragedy

Reach vs Chain Reaction

Don't Stop Movin vs Stomp

Never Had a Dream Come True vs Its The Way You Make Me Feel

Have You Ever vs One For Sorrow

You vs Deeper Shade of Blue

 

it's a close call but I'd say Steps just about edge out S Club overall, despite S Club winning more of these song clashes for me.

S Club 7 | STEPS

Bring It All Back | 5, 6, 7, 8

S Club Party | Tragedy

Reach | Chain Reaction

Don't Stop Movin' | Stomp

Never Had A Dream Come True | It's The Way You Make Me Feel

Have You Ever | One For Sorrow > This was the hardest battle. <

You | Deeper Shade Of Blue

 

S Club 7: 5

STEPS: 3

 

About as expected for me. S Club 7 was definitely the most appealing to me! STEPS had some bops. Funny thing is though, 'It's The Way You Make Me Feel' is my favourite song by either band. :wub:

S Club for them all except the last two!

S Club are cleaning up right now!

S Club for all :blush: I've never bothered much with Steps though Jay is going to be educating me soon *_*

S Club for all :blush: I've never bothered much with Steps though Jay is going to be educating me soon *_*

 

Get yourself educated you don’t know what you’re missing out on!!

I prefer Steps in general, but Don’t Stop Movin’ and Reach win out easily over Steps.

Always liked s club 7 but much prefer steps.

Steps :blush: [Winner: Steps] (I adore both groups)

Bring It All Back [Winner: S Club 7]

Tragedy [Winner: Steps]

Chain Reaction [Winner: Steps]

Don't Stop Movin' [Winner: S Club 7]

It's the Way You Make Me Feel [Winner: Steps]

Have You Ever [Winner: S Club 7]

Deeper Shade of Blue [Winner: Steps]

 

I've never bothered much with Steps though Jay is going to be educating me soon *_*

I'm looking forward to this, I really hope there'll be some Steps songs you take away from it!

 

Claire Richards and Friends forum to be created after that listening session? :magic:

An a club and steps combined forum needs to happen.

S Club 7 for all except Reach.

I love stomp by Steps, shame its up against dont stop moving.