Four songs have been suggested a few times in the main AF Idol thread:

 

Spice Girls - Naked

Emma Bunton - No Sign of Life

Emma Bunton - Too Many Teardrops

Melanie C - Closer

 

Spiceboy and myself are struggling to decide which would be the best one to go with! :o

 

Before you vote: if you could try and think about this more in terms of which song you feel would stand to do the best for us (which might not necessarily be your personal favourite song) that would be helpful. Although if your favourite song happens to also be the song you strongly believe would do well for us, by all means vote for it!

 

To those of you who aren't familiar with some or any of these tracks, it would be brilliant if you're able to have a listen to the songs too. Your fresh perspective would be very useful for us!

 

We appreciate all feedback :wub: Thank you!

 

 

 

 

 

For me it's Too Many Teardrops. It's got the strongest first minute of the options here. It really grabs you from the get-go.

Thanks Michael Andrew!

 

Keep the votes coming *.*

Would be good if people could tell us what they are voting for so we know who has voted what :D

I have voted for Naked but I can't guarantee if that will make my votes...it all depends on the competition!!!

No Sign Of Life :wub:

Was hoping Oxygen would be a choice :cry:

Team 'Naked' :heart:

Oxygen never seems to go down well with most people :(

 

A shame that Spice Girls didn't record a tremendously good ballad for either Spice or Spiceworld that they didn't end up releasing as a single. It's very slim pickings. :( If this round was 'uptempo album track' we'd be spoiled for choice!

Voted 'Naked'. It's really stuck in my head since hearing it earlier tonight, love the laidback production of it! :wub:

 

Those Emma tracks don't strike me as ballads!

Definitely 'Naked'!

 

Not my favourite Spice Girls track (in general), but I do like it!

Thanks for all the feedback so far :wub: We have a clear front runner at the moment *.*

Yep looking like Naked is going to be our submission then. It's quite different for a ballad too so hopefully that will work in our favour. Ps poor Closer not a single vote :cry: it's possibly my favourite track on Northern Star, although it really could do with being shorter lol

 

Ice always loved closer by mel c.

No Sign Of Life. Naked is cool but I don’t think it will get many votes.

Naked out of these four.

They are all great tracks indeed. I think Naked is too much of a risk, but alas, let's see what happens

I’d have opted for Goodnight Kiss by Geri but I’m probably alone in that.

 

Naked sounded pretty bad, think I’d go for an Emma track.

Closer !!

 

 

Shock result for me.

 

Even though I initially felt the Emma tracks weren't all that ballad-y, the way she sings TMT is hauntingly beautiful and emotive.

 

Also rediscovering 'No Sign of Life' - it has given me some 'Too Much' vibes. Even the structure, you could imagine it being sung by the group.

 

Eep. Fingers-crossed.