The casting for this year has been incredible. I really thought the quality would start to nosedive after S3 was a bit weaker in comparison to previous years and we're just quickly following Celebrity Traitors which was a bit of a cultural phenomenon but so far this series has been fantastic! Really pleasantly surprised with it!

I think Faraaz is probably the secret traitor due to metagaming reasons (they would need a POC as a Traitor or people would complain) and he's had fairly limited screen time but Reece could be an option too considering he allowed Rachel/Stephen some alone time at the painting and he didn't find that suspicious unless he already knew they were Traitors...

42 minutes ago, shadow2009 said:

The casting for this year has been incredible. I really thought the quality would start to nosedive after S3 was a bit weaker in comparison to previous years and we're just quickly following Celebrity Traitors which was a bit of a cultural phenomenon but so far this series has been fantastic! Really pleasantly surprised with it!

I think Faraaz is probably the secret traitor due to metagaming reasons (they would need a POC as a Traitor or people would complain) and he's had fairly limited screen time but Reece could be an option too considering he allowed Rachel/Stephen some alone time at the painting and he didn't find that suspicious unless he already knew they were Traitors...

I agree 100% I’m really enjoying it this year definitely the quickest I’ve gotten used to the cast since series 1 I remember it feeling weird seeing a new cast when both series 2 and 3 started but when series 4 came on I didn’t get the weird feeling so deffo and good series this year

1 hour ago, shadow2009 said:

I think Faraaz is probably the secret traitor due to metagaming reasons (they would need a POC as a Traitor or people would complain) and he's had fairly limited screen time but Reece could be an option too considering he allowed Rachel/Stephen some alone time at the painting and he didn't find that suspicious unless he already knew they were Traitors...

I don't think Reece can be as he was shortlisted for Murder wasn't he? And anyone shortlisted by the Secret Traitor couldn't be the Secret Traitor. Although it did cross my mind when he said 'do you want me to leave you two too it' when Stephen and Rachel were with the painting - as if he knew what they had to do.

Faraaz is an interesting one though - he had a bit more screentime in episode 3 and was funny in the picture recreating task too.

I do think though its probably someone with limited screentime, who has been a bit in the shadows, rather than the likes of Amanda who has become very involved and loud.

Edited January 5Jan 5 by ElectroBoy

The wait for tonight has been agonising!

14 minutes ago, Jessie Where said:

The wait for tonight has been agonising!

Agreed! Returning to work this week has actually been a welcome distraction 😂

Edited January 7Jan 7 by T Boy

57 minutes ago, Jessie Where said:

The wait for tonight has been agonising!

FR 4 days too long can't wait :)

Edited January 7Jan 7 by K3

Last guesses for Secret Traitor - Faraaz or Roxy

On 05/01/2026 at 11:23, shadow2009 said:

he allowed Rachel/Stephen some alone time at the painting and he didn't find that suspicious unless he already knew they were Traitors...

Reading those 2 names back to back like this is really fking me up!!! LMAOOOOO. I'm just SO used to seeing "Rachel Stevens" that this just seems wrong and shouldn't be allowed

SO excited for the reveal tonight (although I really do wish they used it for a bit longer) but my final guesses are one of either Ellie or Fiona...

I still think the secret traitor will be a shock

So I’m sticking with Matthew (not just because he’s gorgeous, worked for the ban conversion therapy campaign and he used to play for an inclusive rugby team!), but because he has gone under the radar completely

I have seen some people dislike the concept of the secret traitor. I love it personally as I’ve always said there should be some element to the show that the audience don’t know about - and therefore can’t scream at people for being stupid. Id go as far as to say that some people who don’t like the concept don’t like the loss of control

And when they reveal the secret traitor to Rachel and Stephen but not to us, then what? (really hoping they don’t do this, I can’t take it anymore lmao x)

5 minutes ago, Calum said:

And when they reveal the secret traitor to Rachel and Stephen but not to us, then what? (really hoping they don’t do this, I can’t take it anymore lmao x)

Ngl... I'd LOOOVE this LMAO!

1 hour ago, Tafty said:

Ngl... I'd LOOOVE this LMAO!

100% they should do this

Although mathematically can’t they only keep it a secret until we run out of unknown faithfuls?

Does anyone else think the contestants should have their social media private until the show is over? It seems like so many people are trawling through old Instagram and Facebook posts to deduce clues and connections to other contestants and it just seems like so many people are trying to spoil things for themselves - and others when it gets plastered everywhere! I've already saw some posts on my Facebook feed about old photos on Ross's page and I'm really annoyed because it feels like when Traitors is on you literally can't open a single social media app without some sort of clue/hint/reveal being somewhere.

Oh and you just KNOW in tonight's EP they'll show the reaction to the Secret Traitor and then cut to breakfast and drag out the actual audience reveal until the end of the ep.

Edited January 7Jan 7 by shadow2009

1 minute ago, shadow2009 said:

Does anyone else think the contestants should have their social media private until the show is over? It seems like so many people are trawling through old Instagram and Facebook posts to deduce clues and connections to other contestants and it just seems like so many people are trying to spoil things for themselves - and others when it gets plastered everywhere! I've already saw some posts on my Facebook feed about old photos on Ross's page and I'm really annoyed because it feels like when Traitors is on you literally can't open a single social media app without some sort of clue/hint/reveal being somewhere.

Nah. I guess you have to remember of a portion of people who watch the show, it's only people who engage online who find out all this stuff. People just have way too much time on their hands.

Anyway, excited for tonight. Still going with Fiona/Ellie as the traitor, although I do like the Faraaz shouts as well. Can't wait for everyone to be disappointed! Personally, I've really enjoyed the twist. It's added a fun element to the game. I think they need to do these things to freshen the show up as the cast know the game so it throws them off too. Although I still do enjoy how paranoid people get at the beginning with their theories.

final guess for secret traitor is Fiona

Final guess is Ellie.

So it was Fiona!!!!!!

Its like the embodiment of Amanda from Series 1 🤣

Another Welsh Dragon

Ellie and Ross connection!!!!!!!!

They all must have some form of connection 🤣

The Ellie and Ross connection was so obvious before the reveal going by her reaction as soon as Roxy cast her vote I honestly wouldn't be surprised at this point if Maz is Faraaz's dad (or other relation).

Stephen sadly seems to be totally crumbling to pieces as a traitor so I can't see him lasting much longer at all.