Jump to content

Featured Replies

I remember last month where Zanmatony missed out on qualifying by one single point, though that would have tied me with the 20th place finisher, I believe I would have had higher high scores so would have made it. Perhaps @blacksquare can verify this. I accepted what was though and didn't really care in the long run as it was more of a gimmicky entry for us.

  • Replies 449
  • Views 11.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • THE LIFE OF A DNQ

  • The mundane images being used for the DNQ’s are sending me west. What do you mean Brer & Silas are a silver handle and a piece of toast?!

  • To those of you who stayed with me for this long: thank you! I apologize for the late night show. I can only hope that you enjoyed it, regardless of your result. And I promise I'll try to be even

Posted Images

29 minutes ago, gooddelta said:

But of course, songs getting the high votes and big love should be rewarded too, as many songs that people gave top points to as possible should make the final.

Reading this, and I kind of feel that maybe the most voters method is potentially fairer in some circumstances...

Those that get top 2 scores are already getting advantageous points as 1st gets 2 bonus points and 2nd gets 1 bonus points!

16 minutes ago, awardinary said:

I remember last month where Zanmatony missed out on qualifying by one single point, though that would have tied me with the 20th place finisher, I believe I would have had higher high scores so would have made it. Perhaps @blacksquare can verify this. I accepted what was though and didn't really care in the long run as it was more of a gimmicky entry for us.

Looking back at the ballots, Taahino had two 10s and your top scores were 8s, so you’d still have missed out on the tiebreak

idk I’m just seeing this and I’ve already been having. rough and stressful month with Hawaii being the grace period and I just feel kinda hard done by

dramatic-dmitry-dramatic-dmitry-composit

22 minutes ago, Cody S. Kennedy said:

idk I’m just seeing this and I’ve already been having. rough and stressful month with Hawaii being the grace period and I just feel kinda hard done by

I am convinced you’ll be back and smash even harder next year!!!

Stay positive!!!

Ow, I thought the results were tonight - thanks for the voters for GRANT & Ella - much appreciated!! And of course, thanks to our lovely host!

There were three songs I voted for who missed out;

+12 [QUALIFIED]

+10 [QUALIFIED]

+8 [QUALIFIED]

+7 [QUALIFIED]

+6 Au/Ra – CRACK! {Lentyll} [DID NOT QUALIFY]

+5 [QUALIFIED]

+4 [QUALIFIED]

+3 HALLAN – Solomon {Dalisska} [DID NOT QUALIFY]

+2 B0YG1RL – MOND LAN FINI {Republic of Adonia} [DID NOT QUALIFY]

+1 [QUALIFIED]

Particularly disappointed and surprised not to see Au/Ra in the final, as an already popular artist, with hits to her name, having worked with many big producers. I am a fan of her and much of her output, and have been sitting on one of her featured dance songs for a while now as a potential but didn't submit it.

Unlucky too for Dalisska with their very enjoyable piece, and the sad outcome for the return of Republic of Adonia. Hope both will return in 2027.

Thank you to all who voted Zanmatony through to the final this time.

Very very very happy to be through. I lost half of my votes though!

12

10

8

7

6 Hushkanukia - Abi Carter - Magnetic

5 Aelandor - boy 2000  - dance the night away

4 Spiceland - Maxwell Luke - GIRLFRIEND

3

2 Yehesi - fiveALIVE - UMAMI

1 République d'Áskorza - Felhur X Andro - Bourgeois Jouissent

And Juranabaijan was so close to getting points from me too, an undeserved last place. Listening to the final now and hoping Semi 2 qualifiers can fill the void.

Enjoyed reading the thread though, great job Freeze!

I think someone explained the logic behind it the last time we had this discussion. It makes more sense to go by highest points given, purely for the fact that my 10 pointer is much more likely to get points from me in the final than my 2 pointer.

Neither is perfect, but this did make sense to me.

(See y'all in february, I need a lil' more time to figure out what I'm gonna do for my 100th, Yehesi OUT)

The thing is: as we're only voting for a top 10 in the semis, the 9th best song in someone's votes is worth 2 points. So if 5 people have a song in 9th, that's 10 points - and what's been suggested is that those should be trumped by one person's 10 points for their song in 2nd.

However if we were using the same 15-vote scoring system as the final - which becomes more valid when the semis are large and approaching a comparable size to the final - then those 5 people's 9th placed songs would score 7 points each instead, so 35 points combined - while that one other person's 2nd placed song would score just 15 points, which is nowhere close.

I figured such craziness would happen after revealing the points of the 20th placer in semi 2. 🫣

I am taking some responsibility for that painful miss for Cor Lupus, similarly for Aeroche last contest.

image.gif

Honestly, 1 point difference or a tie doesn’t really matter much at this point, you won’t light up the final board regardless. At the end of the day we are just discussing who is more deserving to finish bottom 10 in the final.

I’ve been a victim of a cruel 16th/21st place semifinal cut myself multiple times (including just last year with Quelza) as well as losing a tie for the 1st place in the final, and I can confidently say that one survives all of this and comes back the following year to slay and finish EOY top 10 x

45 minutes ago, jimwatts said:

The thing is: as we're only voting for a top 10 in the semis, the 9th best song in someone's votes is worth 2 points. So if 5 people have a song in 9th, that's 10 points - and what's been suggested is that those should be trumped by one person's 10 points for their song in 2nd.

However if we were using the same 15-vote scoring system as the final - which becomes more valid when the semis are large and approaching a comparable size to the final - then those 5 people's 9th placed songs would score 7 points each instead, so 35 points combined - while that one other person's 2nd placed song would score just 15 points, which is nowhere close.

I agree with this. Also there’s an assumption that people will love their 10 pointer and not care that much for their 2 pointer which for me is rarely the case. I tend to not have runaway favourites and will like my 2 pointer quite a bit; not that much less than my 10 usually. I think more votes is a fairer tie-break method.

Besides, a little DNQ (or three) does wonders sometimes. My last semi place DNQ this year was a wake up call that pivoted my entries into a direction I never expected to have when starting this year.

1 hour ago, jimwatts said:

The thing is: as we're only voting for a top 10 in the semis, the 9th best song in someone's votes is worth 2 points. So if 5 people have a song in 9th, that's 10 points - and what's been suggested is that those should be trumped by one person's 10 points for their song in 2nd.

However if we were using the same 15-vote scoring system as the final - which becomes more valid when the semis are large and approaching a comparable size to the final - then those 5 people's 9th placed songs would score 7 points each instead, so 35 points combined - while that one other person's 2nd placed song would score just 15 points, which is nowhere close.

But we are not using that system, so this argument doesn't make sense to me. "If my mother had wheels, she would've been a bike" teas

People are gonna miss out on the final, lose their streaks, get annoyed. You can't always win in life. Sure, losing on a tie is a worse feeling than coming 25th, but in the end of the day, the song didn't hit enough people in the right way to get enough points. It is what it is

(Also half the contests I can barely scrape together a top 12 so please an absolute no to the suggestion of 18-1 points for the semi's as well)

I understand the discussion, and I'm not saying songs with broad support aren't valid. I just don't think either metric is perfect on its own, and no system ever will be.

Ultimately we're talking about the fringes of qualification. A song that only just makes the top 20 rarely turns into a big result in the final. Exceptions do exist, of course, but I don't think they change the overall picture

10 minutes ago, Dead Mushroom said:

(Also half the contests I can barely scrape together a top 12 so please an absolute no to the suggestion of 18-1 points for the semi's as well)

No one is suggesting the semis change to the 15-vote system. I'm just suggesting the principle of why that voting system is in place in the final, where it benefits songs which get more votes, should also apply to the tiebreak situations in the semis.

6 minutes ago, jimwatts said:

No one is suggesting the semis change to the 15-vote system. I'm just suggesting the principle of why that voting system is in place in the final, where it benefits songs which get more votes, should also apply to the tiebreak situations in the semis.

I misread the part I thought was a plea for the 18 point system, my apologies.

(Still don't agree with the argument, but that also is life)

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 1