Jump to content

Featured Replies

  1. Sophie Ellis-Bextor - Murder on the Dancefloor

  2. Robyn & Kleerup - With Every Heartbeat

  3. Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

  4. Adele - Skyfall

  5. Zara Larsson & MNEK - Never Forget You

  6. MARINA - Oh No!

  • Replies 50
  • Views 1.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • This year feels particularly harsh (not a criticism of the competition, for the record, not everybody can stay) - I feel like all 6 of these artists left deserve the live shows, and they'd all do real

  • There will be plentiful female artists in live shows, thanks to Calvin Harris!!!

  • Might just put Marina last to punish her label for that horrid retitling x

Posted Images

  1. Sophie Ellis-Bextor - Murder on the Dancefloor

  2. MARINA - Oh No!

  3. Robyn & Kleerup - With Every Heartbeat

  4. Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

  5. Zara Larsson & MNEK - Never Forget You

  6. Adele - Skyfall

Well, this will be the easiest to vote in anyway!

01; Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

02; Robyn & Kleerup - With Every Heartbeat

03; Sophie Ellis-Bextor - Murder on the Dancefloor

04; Adele - Skyfall

05; MARINA - Oh No!

06; Zara Larsson & MNEK - Never Forget You

Don't think the top 3 need any comment, they're not some of the most well regarded songs of their respective eras for no reason. Skyfall still sounds pretty epic, Marina definitely feels like the least ubiquitous here, it's the only one I don't remember that well but it sounded quite good on relisten so let's see if it can weather this. I do quite like the Zara song too, but definitely falling under the weight of this category here.

1 Sophie Ellis-Bextor - Murder On The Dancefloor

2 Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

3 Robyn Ft Kleerup - With Every Heartbeat

4 Adele - Skyfall

5 MARINA - Oh No

6 Zara Larrson & MNEK - Never Forget You

Sophie's has always been a big fave for me even before the revival two years ago so a no brainer and the video is such a joy too. 'Wuthering Heights' a classic too and Robyn's is top notch also. Like 'Skyfall' but don't adore it. 'Oh No' is the only single from this Marina era I recall enjoying somewhat and sounded good listening to it last night. Don't care for 'Never Forget You'.

01 MARINA - Oh No!

02 Robyn & Kleerup - With Every Heartbeat

03 Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

04 Sophie Ellis-Bextor - Murder on the Dancefloor

05 Zara Larsson & MNEK - Never Forget You

06 Adele - Skyfall

Marina and Robyn are the runaway top 2, nothing comes even close. That’s my fav Robyn song ever and I think it will survive so I’ve decided to prioritize Marina there.

Kate Bush and Sophie are undeniable classics. Despite being enjoyable, Murder is slightly overrated. Zara is meh but Skyfall is way too boring to not put it last.

Justice for Agnes.

If we all band together, we can eliminate the remaining ESL artists!! #TheBritFactor

  1. Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights (fave)

  2. Sophie Ellis Bextor - Murder on the dancefloor

  3. Adele - Skyfall

  4. Robyn - With every heartbeat

  5. Marina - Oh no

  6. Zara Larsson - Never forget you

The first 4 are some of my favourite songs and 2-4 could have been in any order on different days tbf. Kate was always going to win with that classic though. Of the remaining two, while I liked both they didn't quite hit the heights of the others for me. Marina was a better track than Zara which was easily the weakest of the lot for me.

  1. SOPHIE (fave)

  2. MARINA

  3. ZARA

  4. KATE BUSH

  5. ADELE

  6. ROBYN

I’ve always felt a bit meh on Robyn’s music compared to other people and I think that’s because the songs never really go anywhere. That’s exactly how I feel about this even though I know it’s hugely popular and has no risk of going at all. The other five are all 10/10s tbh, very hard to split.

21 minutes ago, pavi said:

If we all band together, we can eliminate the remaining ESL artists!! #TheBritFactor

I mean, you could’ve put Mother Larsson a tad higher then hun x

I'll start by saying that my top five in this category I absolutely adore, the artists in this round are fighting for their lives every week!

  1. Robyn & Kleerup - With Every Heartbeat - simply one of the finest songs of all-time, and an incredible moment when she returned from nowhere with this to No.1, and then has since proven time and time again why she is one of the greatest pop stars of any generation

  2. Sophie Ellis-Bextor - Murder on the Dancefloor - it pains me not to put this top, I was so obsessed with this song and Sophie in 2001, and the way it returned again a few years ago to the same amount of success was amazing, it is an absolute disco pop gem and while it may feel like an early play, looking at her top 10 most streamed songs it makes sense to play it here to make sure she gets safely through this round

  3. Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights - one of the most distinctive songs of all-time, again it feels wrong putting it this low. It's a work of genius and influenced so much music and so many artists from that point through to today

  4. Adele - Skyfall - I really loved this at the time and am not big into Bond themes generally but it was classy and dramatic and feels very grand. It's not one I check much these days so was nice to hear it again

  5. MARINA - Oh No! - An absolute gem from The Family Jewels and an easy 9/10 song, I just probably love the others that bit more

  6. Zara Larsson & MNEK - Never Forget You - I never really got into this one unfortunately

01. Robyn & Kleerup - With Every Heartbeat [FAVOURITE]

02. MARINA - Oh No!

03. Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

04. Zara Larsson & MNEK - Never Forget You

05. Sophie Ellis-Bextor - Murder on the Dancefloor

06. Adele - Skyfall

ADORE that top 2! That Robyn song really changed everything for her. What an absolute BEAUT of a song. I've always loved that MARINA song! Such a fun bop and deserved more (well, story of her career tbh!). Kate's and Zara's songs are both ruined by their vocals for me. I find both quite piercing, personally. SE-B song I've enjoyed in the past but I can't really stand it anymore (even before the 'Saltburn' revival!!) and that Adele song has always bored me.

2 hours ago, Lee_J11 said:

I mean, you could’ve put Mother Larsson a tad higher then hun x

Nah I’m good x

01 Robyn - With Every Heartbeat (I don’t think I appreciated this as much as I should’ve at the time but has aged like a fine wine and have finally seen it live - easy number one)

02 Zara Larsson & MNEK - Never Forget You (not amongst my Zara faves but I do think it’s aged very well and the fact I don’t listen to it loads probably helped it stand out - one of Zara’s best vocal moments though)

03 Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights (the highest I’ve put The Bush so far, I think! Probably her best song for me)

04 Marina - Oh No! (not a Marina fave but pretty undeniably a bop of its own right and feels like the right level to send at this point for an artist in the running to win, so smart choice)

05 Sophie Ellis-Bextor - Murder On The Dancefloor (two years ago, this would probably be at #2 as it is a fantastic classic of a pop song - sadly, as I’ve worked in a gay bar for most of the last few years, this has been hammered to death to the point it makes me groan a little and I need a few years for it to recover. Not the fault of the song and very clearly a good choice for Sophie at this point but just a personal thing)

06 Adele - Skyfall (I respect this song and I think it’s one of the better Bond songs but it’s not one I’d ever lean towards playing if I were to mine her back catalogue and feels like the weakest of this pack for me)

This was nooooot easy, I do not envy any of the mentors in this category cos nobody has made a bad choice, it’s just crazily competitive.

FAVE

Sophie Ellis-Bextor - Murder on the Dancefloor

Robyn & Kleerup - With Every Heartbeat

Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

Adele - Skyfall

Zara Larsson & MNEK - Never Forget You

MARINA - Oh No!

LEAST FAVE

01 Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

02 Robyn & Kleerup - With Every Heartbeat

03 Sophie Ellis-Bextor - Murder on the Dancefloor

04 Adele - Skyfall

05 MARINA - Oh No!

06 Zara Larsson & MNEK - Never Forget You

'Wuthering Heights' is one of my favourite songs, so a nailed on #1, but it still feels wild to 'only' rank these Robyn and Sophie classics 2nd and 3rd in a round.

I like everything here to varying degrees so apologies to those lower down.

  1. Kate Bush - Wuthering Heights

  2. Sophie Ellis-Bextor - Murder on the Dancefloor

  3. Robyn & Kleerup - With Every Heartbeat

  4. MARINA - Oh No!

  5. Adele - Skyfall

  6. Zara Larsson & MNEK - Never Forget You

Good choices from everyone.. Kate Bush - absolute clssic, what a vocal performance. SEB with her best song. Robyn with one of her best songs. Against these 3 the others stood no chance for me. I like all 6. Marina with a great choon, Adele also with a great vocal performance. Sorry Zara - I like Never Forget You but against the other 5 I had to put this last.

Oh FFS this round is incredibly hard.

Marina

Kate Bush

Adele - I do like this, I do just think this is the wrong song choice here, I’m worried for her survival here.

Robyn - I see Robyn’s mentor has learnt their lesson to not take their foot off the gas and has pulled out a big classic.

Sophie Ellis-Bextor - the fact that this is 5th and I absolutely love it feels so wrong I’m sorry.

Zara - This just hasn’t stood out in this VERY strong group.

Edited by Viper*

I'm surprised Adele seems to be struggling in this round, that's one of the best Bond songs and she sounds stunning on it (as per!)

Create an account or sign in to comment

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.