Jump to content

AF IDOL 2.0: ROUND 14 • V O T E

-0-0
in AF Idol Archive

Featured Replies

Madonna - Oh Father

Melanie C - Loving You (w/ Matt Cardle)

 

 

Tiebreak

 

Kylie - Love At First Sight :heart:

 

 

 

  • Replies 82
  • Views 5.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Lady Gaga - Marry the Night

Melanie C - Loving You (w/ Matt Cardle)

 

Kylie Minogue - Love at First Sight

 

~

 

I do like Rihanna's song (mainly because of her chorus, more so than any other contributions to that song), but it's last for me. Lady Gaga is an easy first, a Born This Way highlight... a powerful and exhilarating listen. :wub:

 

Melanie vs Madonna was actually really difficult, it didn't merely come down to "I'm a Spice mod". Madonna's song is raw, lyrically and vocally speaking. She doesn't sound at her best, but I know that's because of the sheer emotion of the subject matter. It's a heavy, but beautiful track. Matt/Melanie's song is a great lightning in a bottle moment for the pair of them - it's very catchy, melodic, sexy(!) and their vocals complement each other so well. So they were hard to compare and separate, but ultimately I went with Melanie based on preferring how she sounds vocally.

 

 

~

 

It was very, very hard to choose between Kylie and Little Mix! Love Me Like You is probably Top 5 Little Mix for me! I absolutely adore that song. Love at First Sight is simply one of Kylie's ultimate moments too. I decided that Kylie's gives me slightly more joy~ out of the two.

 

 

S O N G S

 

Madonna - Oh Father

Melanie C - Loving You (w/ Matt Cardle)

 

- T I E B R E A K -

 

Little Mix - Love Me Like You

 

1 Madonna Oh Father

2 Lady gaga - Marry the night

 

the other 2 would be would if they didn't have Matt Cardle and Kaney West

 

Tie Break

Kylie

Madonna - Oh Father

Melanie C - Loving You (w/ Matt Cardle)

 

- T I E B R E A K -

Kylie Minogue - Love At First Sight :wub:

 

Just think, we could have had Love On Top in this round :o

 

1st Lady Gaga - Marry The Night

2nd Rihanna - All Of The Lights

3rd Madonna - Oh Father

4th Melanie C - Loving You (w/ Matt Cardle)

 

- T I E B R E A K -

1st Little Mix - Love Me Like You

2nd Kylie Minogue - Love At First Sight

 

S O N G S

Lady Gaga - Marry The Night

Rihanna - All Of The Lights

 

- T I E B R E A K -

Kylie Minogue - Love At First Sight

 

S O N G S

Madonna - Oh Father

Rihanna - All Of The Lights

 

- T I E B R E A K -

Little Mix - Love Me Like You

1 Madonna Oh Father

2 Lady gaga - Marry the night

 

the other 2 would be would if they didn't have Matt Cardle and Kaney West

 

Tie Break

Kylie

 

Loving You would be so much worse without either Matt or Mel, it’s the two of them together that actually enhance the song.

Edited by T Boy

S O N G S

1. Melanie C - Loving You (w/ Matt Cardle)

2. Lady Gaga - Marry The Night

 

 

x. Rihanna - All Of The Lights

x. Madonna - Oh Father

 

- T I E B R E A K -

✅ Kylie Minogue - Love At First Sight

 

S O N G S

Lady Gaga - Marry The Night

Melanie C - Loving You (w/ Matt Cardle)

 

- T I E B R E A K -

Kylie Minogue - Love At First Sight

 

Just think, we could have had Love On Top in this round :o
OMG!

 

Thank you for making that potential round a bit easier!!!

 

 

 

 

:kink:

Lady Gaga - Marry The Night

Melanie C - Loving You (w/ Matt Cardle)

 

3. Rihanna - All Of The Lights

4. Madonna - Oh Father

 

Kylie Minogue - Love At First Sight

S O N G S

 

1 Lady Gaga - Marry The Night

2 Madonna - Oh Father

3 Rihanna - All Of The Lights

4 Melanie C - Loving You (w/ Matt Cardle)

 

 

 

- T I E B R E A K -

 

1 Little Mix - Love Me Like You

2 Kylie Minogue - Love At First Sight

 

Very sad that I had to put out Kylie, but LM single is their best!

Edited by Nick F1

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
Go to topic listing

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.