Wednesday at 10:512 days 3 minutes ago, Colm said:Ok. We'll all try to post less.You do what you want bro, and I'll do what I want which is read every post 😁 (after putting it off for some time ofc)
Wednesday at 10:542 days As the one who started this impromptu discussion on the rationale for the tiebreak situation, I feel I have a responsibility to say the contest does not need any drastic changes. So thank you Wardy for your suggestion, but I don't see it as a solution to a problem raised here. All I'm suggesting is one small change to how tiebreaks are decided.I agree with Patrick that consistency between the semis and the final would reduce the potential confusion for hosts. Also (and I'm aware that this may be of little interest to those who only participate in BJSC), consistency with other song contests on Buzzjack, which use the same 10-vote, 12 to 1 system as the BJSC semis, but where all tiebreaks are settled by most votes first before 12s and 10s come into consideration. It's an ongoing source of frustration for hosts to present a "final scoreboard" in these contests that they later need to amend to resolve and reverse ties, usually higher up the scoreboard than 20th/21st (and I say this as someone who has lost a tiebreak for 1st/2nd in one such contest where I had received more 12s), when they had expected all contests to use the same system as BJSC.The rules can't be changed once the contest starts, so unfortunately Cor Lupus have to be eliminated in 21st in this occasion. Ironically, Cody benefitted from the opposite tiebreak situation in the final of BJSC 171 with ALT BLK ERA winning against Skall's Blanck Mass in a tiebreak due to having more votes, so it is very much swings and roundabouts in the bigger scheme of things. It's just food for thought for future contests, whether for BJSC 191 or perhaps BJSC 201 onwards.Anyhow I've almost certainly said enough on this for now. Thank you Freeze and mods in the running of the current contest.
Wednesday at 11:272 days Just on the wrong semi syndrome, any views on keeping semi voting compulsory for the semi you’re in, but also making it optional for the opposite semi?(I’m aware it’s swings and roundabouts again as we possibly suffered from wrong semi syndrome this time but had the perfect semi for our 189 entry. Just thinking this might even out the bumps in fortune if you’re from a country who tends to send relatively niche stuff.)
Wednesday at 11:472 days 1 hour ago, blacksquare said:I think Klumzee said it best, and annoying as a tiebreak is, it's something we're all likely to deal with at some pointUnless you are Botanikka x
Wednesday at 11:482 days 57 minutes ago, matto said:You do what you want broMy new favourite matto quote.
Wednesday at 11:492 days i participated some editions in another contest where they do wildcards for picking a song out of the two that finished 1 position below the last qualifier and ended coming top 6 in the grand final so the information being given away that the song almost qualified kinda created a boost which i think might be unfair 👀 but then i also see somewhere else doing wildcards as well and the results don't impact as much though they never come last so i'm not sure how they are revealed or if they are just announced qualifier just like the rest 🤷
Wednesday at 13:322 days My rankings of the SF2 DNQ's btw:+12 | QUALIFIED+10 | QUALIFIED+08 | QUALIFIED+07 | QUALIFIED+06 | QUALIFIED+05 | Kylienips | Anais Vacariu - Eat My Heart Out+04 | Lentyll | Au/Ra - CRACK!+03 | QUALIFIED+02 | Dalisska | Hallan - Solomon+01 | QUALIFIED_14 | Cor Lupus | Maisi and the Disco - Madonna_20 | Vaskla | Matilda Mann - The Fig Tree_22 | FARC | Mckayla Twiggs - What A Girl Wants_23 | Thelonia | Monic - Why Did You Leave_24 | Wholune | Pauline Murray and The Invisible Girls - Dream Sequence 1_28 | New Helvetica | Gaelynn Lea - Someday We’ll Linger in the Sun_30 | Republic of Adonia | B0YG1RL - MOND LAN FINI_31 | Scotland 2 | Lily Chou-Chou - Arabesque_32 | Beaverdonia | TR3N TEN - Bomboclat WallahiSo I really wouldn't have been much help either way too any of these!
Wednesday at 17:252 days 52 minutes ago, pavi said:You never flop [/compliment]Thank you, but it’s worth mentioning that I have my share of flops and DNQs! Especially during BJSC 40-100 era lol. I have 45 DNQ’s under my belt!!!
22 hours ago22 hr I do relate to @matto on the compulsion to read every post in these threads so whew I finally caught up now after missing this when it was live hehe xI did know all the results already as I decided to just jump to the end when I first saw the thread to save the tension (although I see my result was announced very early so there wouldn't have been much of it anyway) + of course have already done the final listenthrough now but still glad I did take the time to read the thread back properly, as I really appreciate the effort and personality put into this thread @Freeze, the cute doggo and buge pics along the way especially (and I've taken Lindsey's suggestion to honour my new identity as a silvery window handle at least temporarily xo I did wonder what was up with Tim becoming a Dead Mushroom lol).As for the actual results... well it's disappointing obviously for me to have DNQed again, just checked and this is the first time in my entire history in the contest that I've DNQed 5 times in one (calendar) year! Although it does mean I've maintained top 20 or bust for the whole year which makes it a bit easier to swallow, I'll probably land in a similar position on the EOY to what I managed last year when I only DNQed twice. And can't say it was a surprise at all that this entry DNQed, it is obviously a niche sound and putting it in a semi-final was bound to be a bigger risk than the similar entries I sent to spinoffs before, plus literally everyone predicted this to DNQ and it didn't get an especially glowing reception on SyncTube to make me doubt that haha.Still, it is my 10th DNQ in a row that still finished at least 24th, and I see it was only 9 points off qualifying, again nearly all of those recent DNQs were also within 12 points of qualifying so could have got there with only one more fan theoretically (PAON and Child's View were a tiny bit further off at 13 and 16 point gaps respectively). Still within the realm of saying that if the semi draws were consistently just marginally more in my favour I could be sitting on a Q streak of 31 now since my last truly clear DNQ (Slauson Malone 1 in BJSC 159 coming 29th with 17 points, 32 away from qualifying). Instead the longest streak I've managed in that period was just 6 Although the same 9 point gap going the other way would have put me almost last in the semi, crazy how close everything is there especially between myself and 28th...!Glad there were some big fans out there for this song although none of them have revealed themselves as of yet (assuming the partial scoreboards for the DNQs are still not forthcoming so I'll have to wait until the end of the contest to find that out). From the posts in the thread I see 4 of my 7 voters but only collectively accounting for 10+? points (thanks for 5 from @pavi, 4 from @Chez Wombat, 1 from @matto and an unspecified number from @Colm that I assume must be 3 points to make the total work out, unless you were one of the three mystery people who gave me medals). xSelf-centred rambling over, here were my votes and DNQ rankings:12 Q10 Q8 Q7 Q6 Q5 Q4 A-Konohagakure3 Q2 Q1 Dobago11th Pestolia12th République d'Áskorza13th Séyetana15th Aelandor18th Hushkanukia19th Spiceland21st Yehesi26th Lotunia30th JuranabaijanDobago are, not for the first time of late, probably the most surprising DNQ of the month for me, why are people not appreciating their quality electronic offerings?! Ok I didn't help tooo much only giving it 1 point but I still thought it'd be safe. Sad but less surprised at A-Konohagakure being out again, they're starting to get a bit up there with the DNQ streak eep but hopefully that should be ending in the next contest... Oop at a bit of a massacre of the songs that just missed out for me, at least it was a bit of a gap from the last qualifier to the rest of the pack so an extra point or two from me might have easily shaken up the order of the DNQs but couldn't have got anything over the line. Spiceland's debut was not bad at all so a shame they didn't quite make it, hope you do stick around @Spiceboy x (and sorry Juranamo as 30th feels harsh, there wasn't actually much in it between that and like 17th for me but someone had to occupy those lower positions oops!)And from my ranking of the other semi:4th Scotland 25th Dalisska9th Republic of Adonia14th Wholune15th New Helvetica17th FARC21st Vaskla25th Kylienips27th Thelonia28th Lentyll29th Beaverdonia32nd Cor LupusNot losing any of my podium from either semi this time but still a slight oof to lose 2 of the top 5 there, I would probably have thought Dalisska would be through aw. Math still not beating his reputation with another non-vote but I see it would have DNQed anyway, thanks for popping by to drop off a banger anyway, see you again some time next year maybe! Aw at New Helvetica's fairytale opening Q streak coming to an end but this would likely have been the first entry of theirs to not get points from me anyway, the instrumental is lovely but I don't really love the sound of her voice unfortunately. FARC is another quite surprising DNQ as that's a pretty solid pop entry I'd have thought, and I wouldn't have bet against Lentyll or Cor Lupus either (though I really didn't like 'Madonna' sorry - fun fact though, I just discovered last night that Maisi And The Disco is Jo Brand's daughter ) Beaverdonia joining the hall of nul pointers fame is iconic, although I'd take this silly earworm any day over the two Kylienips AI entries oop.Speaking of, Kylienips' actual entry this month really wasn't bad either and did deserve to do better - 9 voters but only 19 total points so clearly an extreme case of wide appeal but not specific enough to be competitive. Hmm how does that relate to the can of worms reopened again in the last few pages I think I said my piece about this the last time this was discussed but in case I didn't, I do agree with what Rob said that because there's not really any objectively superior tiebreak system - both ways have their pros and cons - I don't think there's a clear need to change what has been the consistent system for some 15 years, any change to it now would just be retroactively aggrieving a bunch of older DNQs and a whole set of future songs that would now miss out when they wouldn't under the current system. It's all swings and roundabouts and it's just part of the game, same with the inevitability of 'wrong semi syndrome' (which, again, has a corresponding equally inevitable 'right semi syndrome' and you're always more or less equally likely to get either). I suppose there could be some merit to just letting in both songs when there are ties for 20th place but you just know if we did that we'd immediately have a contest that has either both semis having tied 20th places or some crazy 4 or 5 way tie or something - I'd still err towards saying this is a case of not really being a problem that needs to be fixed. And for the record we do (usually x) make sure the hosts are aware of the differing tiebreaks between the semi and the final so it shouldn't be that much of a point of confusion even if it is a bit arcane/unintuitive!I distributed a bunch of reaction spam throughout the thread accordingly but out of the songs that did qualify I will just say (as this post is too long already lol) I am relieved Pagasa did qualify this time so it wouldn't be a potential repeat of Eldritch Anisette DNQing when they would have been my first 18 points to Pagasa. Though we have to wait and see if smush can do that anyway, there are certainly other contenders still
22 hours ago22 hr On 18/11/2026 at 05:50, Dead Mushroom said:(See y'all in february, I need a lil' more time to figure out what I'm gonna do for my 100th, Yehesi OUT)You are actually 2 contests away from your 100th btw On 18/11/2026 at 11:27, Julian_ said:Just on the wrong semi syndrome, any views on keeping semi voting compulsory for the semi you’re in, but also making it optional for the opposite semi?As Rich posted I think those of us with more alt-leaning tastes would probably be more likely to actually partake in this if it was a thing so I likely wouldn't mind this in terms of the effect on the results but I do think it'd be a little structurally unfair compared to just having the pure randomness of the 50/50 draw. xOn 17/11/2026 at 10:44, Klumzee said:Just catching up on these results! Genuinely think both semis may have a record for both the biggest gap between 21st and last place and the smallest gap! Poor Cor Lupus 55 is a crazy amount of points to get and not qualify.You know I can't resist geeking out on another obscure stat so here we go.TL;DR both not quite records unless you put very specific restrictions on one of them, but not far off.The biggest points gaps between the highest and lowest DNQs are unsurprisingly both of the BJSC 100 semis, the only ones which used the 18 point system which majorly distorts things - on face value alone, SF1 had a 77 point gap (102 to 25)* and SF2 had a 66 point gap (108 to 42). There have also been 3 'normal' semis which had gaps larger than 55 points, all in the period not long before the expansion from 15 qualifiers per semi to 20:BJSC 68 SF2 62 points (67 to 5)BJSC 62 SF1 58 points (61 to 3)BJSC 72 SF1 58 points (63 to 5)In the ~modern era~ of 20 Qs per semi it is a record yes - beating BJSC 80 SF2 which had a 53 point gap (55 to 2).There have been 4 semis with a smaller gap than 13 points between the highest and lowest DNQs, including 3 in the modern era:BJSC 161 SF2 9 points (33 to 24)BJSC 39 SF2 10 points (35 to 25)*BJSC 144 SF2 11 points (35 to 24)BJSC 173 SF1 12 points (34 to 22)**these three are all a little distorted by one of the songs in question having a deduction - if the deductions weren't there BJSC 100 SF1 would be 65 points (102 to 37), BJSC 173 SF1 would be 16 points (38 to 22) and BJSC 39 SF2 would actually be slightly tighter at 9 points (36 to 27) - there was never a spreadsheet available to verify that semi but according to the host the last placed song in the semi had a 33% deduction and it appears that without that deduction it actually would have just about qualified...!Neat coincidence that we have such big and small gaps both in the same contest though. xAnyway one more post from me with the slightly less niche stats of the Q streak and then I'm done with the back to back essays
21 hours ago21 hr Qualification streak update (underlined nations have matched or beaten their longest streak to date, streaks that are longer when counting non-consecutive participations are in italics where applicable): 01 32 Danæviia 02 27 Neliönoir 03 13 The Spodic Empire 04 10 Bøtanikkä (non-consecutive: 11) * 05 9 Freidland 06 8 Skall 06 8 Terra Avium 08 7 Elëdan 08 7 Land of DW 08 7 Sovarasma 11 6 Herbilore 11 6 N DNTN 13 5 Lookylion 13 5 Ojnoj 15 4 Altyr Muunilinst 15 4 FSR Rontvia 15 4 Jupiterdonia 15 4 POPHub 19 3 Ajanaeda 19 3 Daehun 19 3 Ennea 19 3 Flynnonda 23 2 Bronzil 23 2 Deandria 23 2 East Rukahavian 23 2 Greenfroze 23 2 Mothertopia 23 2 Pagasa 23 2 Taahino 30 1 Aeroche 30 1 Cheiron 30 1 Harmonica 30 1 Hendinia 30 1 Jadakissnia 30 1 Kluminican Republic 30 1 Macromia 30 1 Mulgracia 30 1 New Lexico 30 1 Summericia (non-consecutive: 2) 30 1 Trifoski 30 1 Zanmatony 30 1 Zephyra Continuum xx (25) Cor Lupus xx (4) New Helvetica xx (3) Séyetana xx (2) Lotunia xx (2) Persephonia xx (2) Scotland 2 xx (2) Thelonia (non-consecutive: 3) xx (1) Dobago xx (1) FARC xx (1) Juranabaijan xx (1) Pestolia xx (1) Yehesi* Bøtanikkä's mid-contest withdrawal from BJSC 180 is not counted as a DNQ for the purposes of this listAfter the big upheaval last month it's back to stability in the top 2 as Danæviia and Neliönoir's national records march on to 32 and 27 respectively to keep them in gold and silver. But there's still a change on the podium again following Cor Lupus' marginal DNQ which now sees The Spodic Empire take their place in the bronze spot, also extending their current national record to 13. Bøtanikkä make sure we stay at 4 countries who have double digit streaks, their current streak hitting 10 as they rise to 4th. Freidland now rise into the top 5 as their national record expands again to 9, still without a top 20 hit in sight yet... there's no new blood in the top 10 as Cor Lupus are the only exit which means the three way tie to 9th shifts to a three way tie for 8th. Notable among those though is Terra Avium's auto-qualifier securing them a national record tie before a single vote was cast - they're at 8 in a row again which they previously managed in BJSCs 174-181 (only BJSC 182 stopping them from currently being on a streak of 17). They also previously got 8 in a row in non-consecutive contests in BJSCs 112-116 & 118-120 so another opportunity for them to make their consecutive record the definitive one now.Herbilore move up to just shy of the top 10 expanding their current record run to 6 in a row, while Ennea outdo their first Q streak and make it to 3 in a row for the first time. Not too much else of note going on although a swift welcome back to Aeroche and Hendinia x (and also welcome back to Macromia and Mulgracia both having their first qualifiers of the year - for a few years in the latter case - after a few DNQs each in their other most recent forays).
17 hours ago17 hr I think I said something similar last month but my streak is probably the shortest in a long long time to be 3rd. I just happened to be in the top 10 when a huge clear out happened. Edited 17 hours ago17 hr by Colm
16 hours ago16 hr Author Thank you for the updates and essays, SilveryWindowHandle😊77 new notifications
16 hours ago16 hr 6 hours ago, SilveryWindowHandle said:I distributed a bunch of reaction spam throughout the thread accordingly😮
16 hours ago16 hr I'm glad you mentioned matto's compulsion to read every post in each thread because I was gonna say you clearly weren't missing any posts hahahaha
15 hours ago15 hr The stats are always amazing (thanks Bre, aka Bror, aka SilveryWindowHandle)Not going to put myself under any pressure to make the top 10 Q streak list at all….
15 hours ago15 hr Love seeing sustained success for the likes of Freidland and Herbilore who have had really good years.And probably one of the best Eledan have done in a year in forever? The entries haven’t by and large been to my taste but they’ve pretty much mastered the formula of sending divisive stuff that hits BIG with those who do connect with.
Create an account or sign in to comment