June 5, 20205 yr Amazing album, one of her best for sure, here's my ranking upon first listen: 1. Rain On Me = 10 2. Plastic Love = 10 3. Sour Candy = 10 4. Babylon = 10 5. Fun Tonight = 10 6. Stupid Love = 9 7. Sine From Above = 9 8. Free Woman = 9 9. 1000 Doves = 8 10. Enigma = 8 11. 911 = 8 12. Replay = 8 13. Alice = 7
June 5, 20205 yr It's difficult to rank still but after quite a few listens I'd say... BRILLIANT: 01 Babylon 02 Sine From Above 03 Rain On Me Good: Alice Stupid Love Fun Tonight 911 Sour Candy Replay Enigma 1000 Doves Okay but definitely wouldn't miss them: 12 Free Woman 13 Plastic Love The order of the ones in good just change around all the time so I won't bother ranking them!
June 5, 20205 yr The top 3 are all some of her absolute best for me now: 01 Sine From Above (+1) 02 Babylon (-1) 03 Rain On Me - 04 Replay (+2) 05 Fun Tonight (-1) 06 911 (+6) 07 Enigma (+4) 08 Free Woman (-3) 09 Alice (-2) 10 1000 Doves - 11 Stupid Love (-3) 12 Sour Candy (-3) 13 Plastic Doll
June 5, 20205 yr Author Let's have a go at re-doing this then, a week on~ 1. Rain On Me 2. Sine From Above 3. Alice 4. Free Woman 5. Stupid Love 6. 1000 Doves 7. Babylon 8. Fun Tonight 9. Enigma 10. 911 11. Sour Candy 12. Replay 13. Plastic Doll 1. Sine From Above (+1) 2. Rain On Me (-1) 3. Alice (=) 4. Free Woman (=) 5. 911 (+5) 6. Enigma (+3) 7. Babylon (=) 8. Replay (+4) 9. 1000 Doves (-3) 10. Stupid Love (-5) 11. Fun Tonight (-3) 12. Sour Candy (-1) 13. Plastic Doll (=) Honestly - every day new songs creep up on me. I can't remember the last album where my favourites kept switching like this. I think it's because the entire album is strong, so depending on my mood or what lyrics I focus on, a different song affects me. What an album :wub:
June 5, 20205 yr 5. 911 (+5) '911' also jumped to #05 for me :heart: Up 4 places from last time. It seems to be a grower for a lot of people!
June 6, 20205 yr Sine From Above so low for you Supercell! :( Sorry! It just doesn't do it for me, but its not by any means a bad song. Like that Replay is climbing up on everyones lists though, such a banger!
June 6, 20205 yr '911' could be jumping into my top 3 very soon. I can't believe how underwhelmed I was on first listen and now I'm SHOOK at what a banger it is
June 7, 20205 yr 01. Fun Tonight {--} 02. Sine From Above {+1} 03. Rain On Me {-1} --- 04. Alice {--} 05. Sour Candy {--} 06. Babylon {+2} 07. Love Me Right {-1} 08. 1000 Doves {-1} 09. 911 {+3} 10. Plastic Doll {+1} 11. Free Woman {-1} 12. Stupid Love {-3} 13. Replay {--} 14. Enigma {--} My top 3 is more or less set in stone. The order between them 3 may change, but they're still the main 3! :lol: Who knew the Elton John collab would be fighting for the top spot over Ariana and BLACKPINK collabs!? Wbk. I like everything up to (and including) 'Stupid Love'. I go through moments with both 'Replay' and 'Enigma'. 'Replay' I prefer listening through my headphones (and with me not travelling much atm, I haven't experienced that as much). 'Enigma' I just find a bit too shouty and irritating, but some listens it works but most listens... nah.
June 7, 20205 yr If there’s ever a Chromatica survivor the results would be so interesting. It’s an interesting album as there’s no fan favourite (s).
June 7, 20205 yr It does seem like everyone has widely different choices. Mine is mostly the opposite of Jonjo here... I love the growling in 'Enigma' for example 01 Babylon 02 Replay 03 Enigma 04 Rain on Me 05 Alice 06 Sine from Above 07 911 08 Free Woman 09 1000 Doves 10 Fun Tonight 11 Stupid Love 12 Sour Candy 13 Plastic Doll That top seven are all so solid. 'Free' Woman' has really grown on me, I still wish the drop wasn't so basic, but the rest is great.
June 7, 20205 yr 1. Rain On Me 2. Stupid Love 3. Sour Candy 4. Babylon 5. Sine From Above 6. Alice 7. Replay 8. Free Woman 9. Enigma 10. 1000 Doves 11. Fun Tonight 12. 911 13. Plastic Doll 1. Stupid Love (+1) 2. Rain On Me (-2) 3. Alice (+3) 4. Babylon (--) 5. Fun Tonight (+6) 6. Sour Candy (-3) 7. Free Woman (+1) 8. Sine From Above (-3) 9. 911 (+3) 10. Replay (-3) 11. 1000 Doves (-1) 12. Enigma (-3) 13. Plastic Doll (--) it's switching all the time! :cry:
June 7, 20205 yr Author If there’s ever a Chromatica survivor the results would be so interesting. It’s an interesting album as there’s no fan favourite (s). We definitely need this! Maybe once the album has had a bit more time to settle in :D
June 7, 20205 yr 'Free' Woman' has really grown on me, I still wish the drop wasn't so basic, but the rest is great. Agreed!
June 7, 20205 yr I've just done one of those song sorter games and this is my ranking after a week and a bit: 01 Alice 02 Sine From Above (with Elton John) 03 Rain On Me (with Ariana Grande) 04 Stupid Love 05 911 06 Babylon 07 Sour Candy (with BLACKPINK) 08 Replay 09 Enigma 10 Free Woman 11 Plastic Doll 12 1000 Doves 13 Fun Tonight I still feel like I'm missing the hype for Free Woman and Fun Tonight in particular - they're some of the most generic forgettable moments for me on the album.
June 11, 20205 yr 01 (01) Sine From Above 02 (02) Rain on Me 03 (05) 911 04 (03) Alice 05 (04) Plastic Doll 06 (09) Babylon 07 (10) Replay 08 (06) 1000 Doves 09 (07) Fun Tonight 10 (08) Free Woman 11 (11) Stupid Love 12 (12) Sour Candy 13 (13) Enigma
June 11, 20205 yr 1. Fun Tonight 2. Sine From Above 3. Rain on Me 4. Babylon 5. 1000 Doves 6. Free Woman 7. 911 8. Stupid Love 9. Plastic Doll 10. Sour Candy 11. Enigma 12. Alice 13. Replay 1. Fun Tonight = 2. Sine From Above = 3. Rain on Me = 4. Alice (+8) 5. 1000 Doves = 6. Free Woman = 7. Stupid Love (+1) 8. Babylon (-4) 9. 911 (-2) 10. Enigma (+1) 11. Plastic Doll (-2) 12. Replay (+1) 13. Sour Candy (-3) Even looking at a revised list I still don't feel 100% happy with it :lol: - top 3 and bottom 2 are spot on, but everything in between is so interchangeable!
June 11, 20205 yr 1. Rain On Me (w/ Ariana Grande) 2. Free Woman 3. 911 4. Plastic Doll 5. Sour Candy (w/ BLACKPINK) 6. 1000 Doves 7. Alice 8. Fun Tonight 9. Sine From Above (w/ Elton John) 10. Enigma 11. Stupid Love 12. Babylon 13. Replay After 6 listens. It’s getting harder and harder to rank them as all the 8/9’s out of 10 are just turning into 10/10’s lmao 1. Rain On Me (with Ariana Grande) 2. Free Woman 3. 911 4. Sine From Above (with Elton John) 5. 1000 Doves 6. Sour Candy (with BLACKPINK) 7. Alice 8. Plastic Doll 9. Fun Tonight 10. Enigma 11. Replay 12. Babylon 13. Stupid Love 14. Love Me Right Replay and Sine From Above have only gone up and up in my estimation. Crazy how the lead single is now my least favourite out of the standard-album tracks. This whole record is still PHENOMENAL. :heart:
June 11, 20205 yr Babylon is really growing on me now!! But this album is so hard to rank because I love everything on it.
